Planning a Christmas getaway or summer holiday? One of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to book a cattery or hire a cat sitter. Both options keep your cat safe whilst you’re away, but they offer very different experiences.
There’s no universally “right” answer – what works beautifully for one cat might be completely wrong for another. The key is understanding your individual cat’s personality, needs, and preferences, then making an informed choice that prioritises their well being.
In this guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both catteries and home cat sitting, helping you decide which option will keep your beloved cat happiest and most comfortable whilst you enjoy your time away.
What is a cattery?
A cattery is a licensed boarding facility where cats stay in individual pens or units whilst their owners are away. Think of it as a hotel specifically designed for cats.
How catteries work
Modern catteries provide secure, enclosed spaces for each cat, usually with an indoor sleeping area and an outdoor run. Your cat stays in their designated space for the duration of your trip, with staff providing daily feeding, cleaning, and basic interaction.
Most catteries require up-to-date vaccination records to protect all the cats in their care. You’ll typically need to provide your cat’s food, or they’ll feed a standard diet they provide.
Standards and regulations
In the UK, catteries must be licensed by the local council and meet specific welfare standards. This includes requirements for space, hygiene, heating, and daily care routines.
However, standards can vary significantly between facilities. Some catteries offer luxury suites with comfortable furnishings and enrichment, whilst others provide more basic accommodation.
What is professional cat sitting?
Professional cat sitting means an experienced carer visits your home to look after your cat whilst you’re away. Your cat stays in their own familiar environment rather than going elsewhere.
How cat sitting works
A cat sitter visits your home once or twice daily (depending on your cat’s needs) to provide feeding, fresh water, litter tray cleaning, medication if needed, and companionship through play and cuddles.
Professional cat sitters also provide home security benefits – they can collect post, water plants, adjust lighting or curtains, and generally keep your home looking occupied.
What to expect from professional sitters
Reputable cat sitters are insured, often DBS checked, and have experience with various cat personalities and needs. Many provide photo updates via text or email so you can see how your cat’s doing whilst you’re away.
The best cat sitters take time to meet you and your cat before your trip, learning your cat’s routine, preferences, and any specific care requirements.
Pros and cons of catteries
Catteries suit some cats and situations perfectly, whilst not being the right fit for others. Let’s look at both sides.
Advantages of catteries
- Supervision and security: Your cat has 24/7 oversight with staff on-site. If something goes wrong, someone’s there immediately to respond.
- Social interaction: Staff interact with cats throughout the day, and some cats enjoy watching other cats in nearby pens (without direct contact).
- Regulated environment: Licensed catteries must meet specific standards, giving you peace of mind about basic care quality.
- Good for long trips: For extended holidays, catteries can be more cost-effective than multiple daily cat sitting visits.
Disadvantages of catteries
- Stress of transport: Many cats find being removed from their territory extremely stressful. The car journey, unfamiliar environment, and different smells can be overwhelming.
- Exposure to illness: Despite vaccination requirements, there’s always a risk of picking up infections when multiple cats share a facility. Stress can also lower immune responses.
- Routine disruption: Even the best cattery can’t perfectly replicate your cat’s home routine, feeding schedule, or familiar environment.
- Unsuitable for anxious cats: Cats with anxiety, elderly cats, or those with health conditions often struggle significantly in catteries.
Limited one-to-one time: With multiple cats to care for, staff time with each individual cat is necessarily limited.
Pros and cons of cat sitting
Home cat sitting offers a completely different experience. Again, there are clear advantages and some potential drawbacks to consider.
Advantages of cat sitting
- Familiar environment: Your cat stays in their own territory with all their familiar smells, hiding spots, and routines. This significantly reduces stress.
- Personalised care: Cat sitters can follow your exact routine – feeding times, play preferences, medication schedules, and individual quirks.
- No travel stress: Your cat avoids the anxiety of car journeys and being transported to an unfamiliar location.
- Home security: Your home remains occupied-looking with someone regularly checking in, reducing burglary risk.
- Better for anxious or elderly cats: Cats with health issues, anxiety, or mobility problems almost always cope better at home.
- Flexible visiting schedule: You can arrange once or twice-daily visits depending on your cat’s needs and your budget.
Disadvantages of cat sitting
- Less supervision: Your cat isn’t monitored constantly between visits. If something happens between scheduled visits, it won’t be noticed immediately.
- Relies on one person: If your cat sitter becomes ill or has an emergency, backup arrangements are crucial (however reputable sitters always have these in place).
- Trust factor: You’re giving someone access to your home and trusting them with your beloved cat. This requires thorough vetting and clear communication.
Ready to use a cat sitter?
Special Offer for New Customers. Receive 2 FREE visits when you book your first cat sitting visits with us! Experience the peace of mind that comes with professional, loving cat care.
Which cats thrive with cat sitters?
Some cats are clear candidates for home care. If your cat fits these descriptions, a cat sitter is likely the better choice.
Anxious or nervous cats
If your cat is easily stressed, hides when strangers visit, or struggles with change, staying home is almost always preferable. The familiar environment helps them cope with your absence much better.
Anxious cats in catteries often refuse to eat, hide constantly, and can develop stress-related health issues like cystitis.
Senior cats and those with health conditions
Older cats benefit enormously from maintaining their established routine. They’re also more vulnerable to stress and illness in unfamiliar environments.
Cats with conditions like diabetes, kidney disease, or hyperthyroidism need consistent medication timing and monitoring. A cat sitter can provide this personalised care at home.
Indoor-only cats
Cats who’ve never been outside often find catteries particularly overwhelming. The sounds, smells, and proximity of other cats can be extremely stressful.
Home cat sitting keeps their world consistent and predictable.
Cats who dislike car travel
If your cat becomes distressed during car journeys – vocalising, panting, drooling, or toileting in the carrier – the trauma of getting to and from a cattery adds unnecessary stress.
Very attached or social cats
Some cats are deeply bonded to their owners and struggle when you’re away. These cats benefit from the extra attention and companionship a cat sitter provides through play sessions and cuddles.
Which cats might suit catteries?
Whilst home care suits most cats, some genuinely do fine in catteries or may even prefer them in specific circumstances.
Confident, adaptable cats
Some cats are naturally laid-back and adapt well to new environments. If your cat is curious, friendly with strangers, and generally unfazed by change, they might handle a cattery perfectly well.
Look at past behaviour – has your cat coped well with previous cattery stays? Have they stayed calm during vet visits or house moves?
Cats who've experienced catteries positively before
If your cat has successfully stayed in a cattery previously and showed no signs of stress – eating normally, appearing relaxed, no illness afterwards – they’re likely fine with this arrangement.
Some cats genuinely don’t mind cattery stays, particularly if they started young.
When home access is complicated
If your home is undergoing building work, has unreliable heating, or access is genuinely difficult, a cattery provides consistent conditions and easier logistics.
Outdoor cats who hunt
Cats who regularly hunt might struggle with not having outdoor access during home cat sitting (though this depends on your sitter’s approach and your home setup). Some outdoor cats adapt fine, whilst others become frustrated.
Making your decision: Key questions to ask
Still unsure whether to choose a cat sitter or cattery? Here are some questions to consider:
- How does your cat typically respond to change? Cats who hide when furniture moves or visitors arrive will likely struggle in catteries.
- Has your cat been to a cattery before? Past experience is the best predictor. How did they cope?
- Does your cat have health issues or need medication? Complex health needs are usually better managed at home with personalised care.
- How long will you be away? Very short trips might make catteries more cost-effective, whilst longer holidays might tip the balance the other way depending on visit frequency.
- What’s your budget? Compare costs, but remember the cheapest option isn’t always best for your cat’s well being.
- How important is constant supervision to you? If you’d worry constantly about your cat being alone between visits, a cattery might give you more peace of mind.
- Can you find a reputable, trustworthy option? Whether cattery or cat sitter, quality matters enormously. A poor cattery is worse than no cattery, and an unreliable cat sitter creates more problems than they solve.
Finding quality care: What to look for
Whichever option you choose, quality and reliability are paramount.
Vetting a cattery
Visit in person before booking. The facility should smell clean, look well-maintained, and feel calm. Watch how staff interact with the cats – do they seem genuinely caring?
Ask about their routine, how they handle emergencies, and what happens if your cat becomes unwell. Check their licence is current and read recent reviews from other cat owners.
Trust your instincts. If something feels off or the cattery seems chaotic, keep looking.
Choosing a cat sitter
Meet potential sitters before committing. They should ask detailed questions about your cat’s routine, personality, and any health concerns. Professional cat sitters should be insured and willing to provide references.
Check they’re insured, ask about their experience with cats, and discuss their backup plan if they’re unwell. Request references and actually contact them.
A good cat sitter will want to meet your cat before your trip and will provide clear communication about visit timing and updates whilst you’re away.
Cost comparison: Cat sitter or cattery?
Budget matters, but it shouldn’t be the only deciding factor. Let’s break down typical costs.
Cattery costs
Catteries typically charge per day, with prices ranging from £10-25 per day depending on location and facility quality. Some offer discounts for longer stays.
You’ll often pay the full rate even if you’re only away part of a day – if you drop off in the morning and collect the next evening, you’re charged for two days.
Cat sitting costs
Cat sitters usually charge per visit, with rates varying by location, visit length, and frequency. Expect £12-18 per visit typically, with some sitters offering package deals for multiple daily visits.
For a week away with once-daily visits, you’re looking at around £84-126. Twice-daily visits would roughly double this.
The real value consideration
Don’t just compare numbers – consider what you’re actually getting. A stressed, unwell cat returning from a cattery might need vet visits that far exceed any initial saving.
Your cat’s well being and your peace of mind have real value that goes beyond the basic price tag.
Conclusion
The cat sitter or cattery decision isn’t about which option is objectively better – it’s about which one suits your individual cat’s personality, health, and needs.
For most cats, staying home with a professional cat sitter provides the least stressful experience. The familiar environment, consistent routine, and personalised care help cats cope beautifully with their owner’s absence. This is especially true for anxious cats, seniors, and those with health conditions.
However, some confident, adaptable cats genuinely do fine in quality catteries, particularly if they’ve had positive previous experiences or if practical factors make home care difficult.
The key is being honest about your cat’s temperament and needs rather than choosing based purely on cost or convenience. Watch how your cat responds to change, consider their past experiences, and trust your instincts about what will make them most comfortable.
Whichever option you choose, prioritise quality and reliability. Your cat deserves the best care possible whilst you’re away.
Looking for an in-home cat sitter?
Our professional cat sitting service keeps your cat happy, healthy, and stress-free in their own familiar environment whilst you’re away. With personalised care, regular updates, and the peace of mind that comes with experienced, insured sitters, your cat gets the individual attention they deserve.